Shabad Kirtan: Sukhwinder Singh (Playback Singer) | Bhai Gagandeep Singh (Sri Ganga Nagar Wale). Thank you Jio for the soulful kirtan. (Source: You Tube – Bhai Gagandeep Singh Sri Nagar Wale)
by Harnaak Singh
In Part 4A, in which we moved focus to Malaysia, we discussed three major matters i.e.
- The relationship between FAITH and REASON, LOGIC and CRITICAL THINKING (RLC),
- Showed how Karminder and the Kala Afghana Brigade uses RLC to break down long standing tenets and create new knowledge to replace this,
- Exposed the links between MGC and KARMINDER with the Kala Afghana Brigade and Ideology.
The first dot point FAITH vs RLC is a very important and critical point for us all to understand.
In Part 4A we discussed this with an example of a person crossing the road and then went on the show how Karminder and the Kala Afghana Brigade use RLC to propagate the Kala Afghana Ideology with two examples, one on Sikhi tenets and one on our historical records.
In this part we will look into this with two more examples. The examples show the thought process of the indoctrinated Kala Afghana members.
One of the Kala Afghana Brigade members, Rajinder Singh Sikh made a comment on the article 4A. Article 4A can be viewed at Gurvichar at LINK.
The comment by Rajinder Singh Sikh is shown in Figure 1. The example analyses his thinking of content of the article Part 4A.
Then we look at another example posted in Figure 2 related to LIVING GURU.
For the ensuing discussion remember that Rajinder Singh Sikh’s thinking is hinged on reason, logic and critical thinking (RLC) which is a major Kala Afghana Ideology characteristic.
ANALYSIS – Example 1: Fallacy and Worship
Rajinder Singh Sikh is one of the Kala Afghana Brigade members who appears to have been well indoctrinated.
Figure 1: Comment by Rajinder Singh Sikh
First let us once pen the summary of what was in the article 4A. We discussed three major matters in article 4A i.e.
- The relationship between FAITH and REASON, LOGIC and CRITICAL THINKING (RLC) in the inner-self,
- Showed how Karminder and the Kala Afghana Brigade uses RLC to break down long standing tenets and create new knowledge to replace these,
- Exposed the links between MGC and KARMINDER with the Kala Afghana Brigade and Ideology.
We assume that Rajinder Singh’s comment is directed at the writer of the article.
What is Rajinder Singh Sikh’s opinion of the article. He thinks
- the article is a Mega FALLACY,
- it is a conspiracy by organised and institutionalised Sikhi,
The purpose of this conspiracy is
- to create the need to perform FORMAL prayers; worship to be spiritual, liberated, enlightened, AND
- construct places of worship
We will discuss each of these numbered points in sequence
Point 1: Mega Fallacy
A fallacy is a misconception resulting from incorrect reasoning.
From Rajinder Singh Sikh’s comment it appears that (A), (B) and (C) are all fallacies.
As regards (A) Faith and RLC; the concept was developed over a period of time in the logic series of articles at Gurvichar (a complete set is attached for the Sangat to download). This lead the concept of inner self which is pictorially summarised in Figure 2 below (this was also used in article 4A).
Figure 2: Our inner-self, faith and reason, logic and critical thinking
The concept in this figure resulted from a study of physical science, metaphysical science and Gurbani. If our learned Rajinder Singh Sikh is saying this is fallacy then all we can say is GOD HELP HIM.
HOWEVER we can understand why he is making this statement. Since his RLC does not believe in the link to the higher consciousness, then of course the concept shown in Figure 2 is false because he sees it as in Figure 3. He has no FAITH and no DEVOTION i.e. no SHARDA.
Figure 3: Our inner-self, devoid of SHARDA, devotion and faith
Rajinder Singh Sikh appears to have been indoctrinated to rely totally and exclusively to reason, logic and critical thinking as well as INDOCTRINATED into the Kala Afghana Ideology. His knowledge base is narrowed down to the Kala Afghana Ideology whereby his masters have distorted the TRUE GURMAT (Guru’s teaching). With this limited knowledge he cannot understand Figure 2 and what TRUE Gurmat is. So to his limited mind and knowledge, Figure 2 is a fallacy.
Now one thing that often helps is the intuitive link to the higher consciousness. This link can give us an inkling the something is not right with our thinking. BUT if this intuitive link to the higher consciousness is DEAD, i.e. not there then the person is nothing more than a ROBOT or ZOMBIE, totally controlled by the Kala Afghana Ideology.
As regards (B) and (C), we have presented evidence from documents that originated form the Kala Afghana Brigade members. Again our conclusion in (B) and (C) CANNOT BE FALSE. The same limited knowledge and RLC paranoia of Rajinder Singh Sikh limits him from accepting the FACTS and hence the TRUTH.
He lives in a FALSE Gurmat WORLD, like
- a blind man cannot see light and
- a blind inner-self cannot see the truth.
Both are ruined by REASON, LOGIC and CRITICAL THINKING, being EMPTY of SHARDA, the link to the HIGHER CONSCIOUSNESS GOD.
Point 2: Conspiracy by organised and institutionalised Sikhi
He says that the article is a conspiracy. A conspiracy is a plot to carry out some harmful or illegal act.
What is the illegal act in the article.
Point (A) which is based on physical science, metaphysical science and Gurbani?
Point (B) and (C) which is based on FACTS using the KA member documents?
Come-on Rajinder you could do better than that. Give us some evidence of what you claim.
No evidence? No surprise! Not unexpected of Moorakhs.
Of course there is none because it is a FALLACY that your masters told you. INDOCTRINATION? Your masters can do no wrong!
Points 3 and 4: Need to perform FORMAL worship and build places of worship
This is really WARPED thinking of a confused person. Nowhere in the article Part 4A is there indication of building or propagating a place of worship. NOT in (A), (B) or (C).
My friend, you really seem to be DEEP in the INDOCTRINATION of your MASTERS the Kala Afghana Brigade. You are confused and cannot read and decipher properly. We pity you. God help you.
ANALYSIS – Example 2: Living Guru
Another interesting example from the sagas of Rajinder Singh Sikh worth an analysis is shown in Figure 4.
Figure 4: SGGS Living Guru or a Book (Granth)
Figure 4 is a discussion between two of the Kala Afghana members about the status of SGGS Ji. Essentially the crux of the discussion is that both these Kala Afghana Ideology suckers don’t believe in the concept of LIVING GURU. They are talking of SGGS Ji as a “BOOK”. They forget what Guru Gobind Singh Ji told us when he edicted us to take SGGS Ji as our GURU. Consider the verse in this dohra we recite every day.
Guru Granth Ji Maaneo, Pargat Guran Di Deh.
BELIEVE (Maaneo) that Guru Granth is LIVING (Pargat) BODY (Deh) of GURUS.
Even while reciting this daily (assuming that they do) these people don’t believe in what the Dohra reminds us day in day out. I shake my head at the EMPTINESS of their inner-self DEVOID OF THE LINK TO THE HIGHER CONSCIOUSNESS.
The explanation of their behaviour lies in the 100% RLC biased thinking, see Figure 3. Based on RLC, HOW CAN A BOOK (more a Granth than a book) be a LIVING ENTITY. Only with SHARDA, the link with the higher consciousness, can one accept SGGS Ji as a LIVING GURU.
I rest my case.
SUM-UP AND CONCLUSION
A blind man cannot see the light. A blind inner-self cannot see truth.
Both are ruined by REASON, LOGIC and CRITICAL THINKING and EMPTINESS of SHARDA the link to the HIGHER CONSCIOUSNESS GOD.
The picture in Figure 3 tells the tale. NO FAITH/NO DEVOTION means NO INTUITION.
What is the impact of this on us. Sangat Ji you can clearly see in the analysis above the thinking and behaviour of the people who operate purely on reason, logic and critical thinking.
We do not want to be ROBOTS or ZOMBIES like them. And our children will be totally run by REASON, LOGIC AND CRITICAL THINKING. They will become LIKE MACHINES, ROBOTS, ZOMBIES.
Our children will lose their capability to INNOVATE and will end up like people were, before our Gurus came along and taught the WISDOM of Gurbani. The future generation will be subservient to their Kala Afghana masters.
PLEASE SANGAT JI, UNDERSTAND the disastrous situation we are putting our FUTURE GENERATION into by getting rid of their intuitive powers.
Exercise of TRUE GURBANI develops intuitive powers. It is this power that makes us RISE TO THE OCCASION.
SANGAT JI, DON’T short change our future generation.
DON’T LISTEN TO THESE MOORAKS who propagate the KALA AFGHANA IDEOLOGY.
Please spend some time to understand the above and also Part 4A and realise what will be lost by losing our SHARDA/INTUITION.
THE ONLY SOURCE OF INTUITIVE POWER IS THE HIGHER CONSCIOUSNESS. This can be developed by TRUE Gurbani teaching.
REASON, LOGIC and CRITICAL THINKING is just a FALLACY, which we think is the solution to FAITH. The two actually are at ODDs.
That’s all for now. We will continue ….
Thank You for reading. ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕਾ ਖਾਲਸਾ ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂ ਜੀ ਕੀ ਫਤਹਿ
… to be continued.
Please download the PDF attached and share: 171015 Wreck the SRM History MSIA 4B
Logic series articles ALL in one PDF for download: 171115 Logic Resasoning Gurbani ALL GV